web analytics
How can we reach you?
Send along your info and we'll contact you.

Incentives May Not Trump Culture


Why did your incentive program fail?  Maybe because you focused the program on “sacred values.”

Company/corporate culture is a hot discussion these days.  From @zappos (everyone take a drink) and Netflix – every company wants to be the “it” girl of corporate culture.  Culture drives engagement they say.  Much corporate treasure is spent to reward behaviors that drive the culture the company has, or hopes to have.

But recent research may show that your reward program has less effect on culture than you think, and in fact, may be wasted money.

An article entitled “When the brain refuses to take the cash” was published on Futurity.org yesterday that discussed an experiment where they looked at people’s brains using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) while they were offered cash incentives to change a belief.   What they found was pretty interesting from a reward and recognition point of view…

“Our experiment found that the realm of the sacred—whether it’s a strong religious belief, a national identity or a code of ethics—is a distinct cognitive process,” says Gregory Berns, director of the Center for Neuropolicy at Emory University and lead author of the study published in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society.
Sacred values prompt greater activation of an area of the brain associated with rules-based, right-or-wrong thought processes, the study shows, as opposed to the regions linked to processing of costs-versus-benefits.

Their conclusions – rewards may not affect behavior when that behavior comes from a “sacred belief.”

“Most public policy is based on offering people incentives and disincentives,” Berns says. “Our findings indicate that it’s unreasonable to think that a policy based on costs-and-benefits analysis will influence people’s behavior when it comes to their sacred personal values, because they are processed in an entirely different brain system than incentives.”

A Little Word Substitution Game

Let’s just take their words and play a bit – change “national identity” in the first pullquote to “corporate identity” (and I’d even stretch that to “corporate culture.”)  And then let’s just change the word “public policy” in the second pullquote to something like say, “company values” or company rules, or just go with company policy.

Now think about what the research may be hinting at…

Offering incentives to change how people act in relation to rules/policy in a company where the rules are based on corporate culture/identity won’t be very effective.

Hmmm….. what to do, what to do….

Back to the article:

“Organized groups may instill values more strongly through the use of rules and social norms,” Berns says.

Rules and social norms.  Where have we heard that before… Oh yeah, recognition works on the rules and social norms.

When we have rules (the stated behaviors we want) and we recognize people for doing those behaviors we create social norms.  Therefore, recognition is a better way to reinforce a culture and over time, reinvent it at your company. 

Remember… incentives are “do this then that” awards and recognition is after the fact – not a promised contract for change.

All Culture Change Starts With an Existing Culture

If you are seeking to change your company’s culture remember you are already starting with a culture – a set of beliefs held by your employees. 

Simply adding incentives to change behavior may not work if the change you’re trying to reinforce with the incentive is contrary to a company sacred value – the participant (employee) won’t feel it the in the reward center of their brain.  I’ve set this before – incentives are choice architectures – and this research would seem to say that when incentives are used to change strongly held beliefs they don’t register in the choice part of the brain – therefore – no real “choice” is made.

Now – let me head off some of the haters.  I’m just wool-gathering here – playing with an idea so don’t point out that the research really didn’t say what I just concluded.  I know that.

What I am suggesting is that this research could be interpreted as programs designed to either create, change or reinforce behaviors around culture in an organization should be looked at from a recognition standpoint – not necessarily an incentive point of view.  Especially if the change goes to core beliefs and values in an organization.

If you run a boiler-room – don’t think running an incentive to be more “touchy feely” is going to work.  You’d be better off, over time, recognizing and rewarding behaviors than trying to motivate them.   Remember – those are two different things.

What do you think?  Am I stretching this a bit to make a point or do you think there some some gold flakes in here worth mining?


Originally posted on on Incentive Intelligence

9 Responses to “Incentives May Not Trump Culture”

  1. […] the whole post at Paul Hebert’s I-2-I  (an FOT Contributor Blog) jQuery(document).ready(function($) { […]

  2. […] Incentives may not trump culture over at i2i (one of my favorite blogs), Paul Hebert argues that if we want to change a culture, we […]

  3. Talitha Akin says:

    I agree to a certain extent. I think this idea has a touch of Herzberg thinking. The more ‘shallow’ motivators such as money are not going to be anywhere near as effective in achieving buy in and change as recognition for the leader. However this also needs to be complimented by the leaders walking the talk and modeling the expected behaviours. While this does not act as a recognition or a motivator it is essential to the process. All in all it’s about addressing values and behaviours which I agree, take a lot more to influence that incentives, however recognition is just part of the process.

    • Paul Hebert says:

      Thanks for commenting Talitha.  I agree it is a combo platter with incentives and recognition.  What I was really intrigued by was that when trying to change or go against belief systems the rewards don’t really register the same way – in other words the incentive is almost a non-issue.  To me that brings up all kinds of questions on how and what you recognize in a comapny.

  4. […] conversation stemmed from a recent piece he did on his blog about the role that money plays in relation to highly placed values and culture. He said in that post: If you are seeking to change your company’s culture remember you are […]

  5. […] Incentives May Not Trump Culture Recent CommentsPaul Hebert on Why Do We Love to Work at Companies Where We Don’t Have to Work?Frank on Why Do We Love to Work at Companies Where We Don’t Have to Work?Paul Hebert on Why Do We Love to Work at Companies Where We Don’t Have to Work?Monthly Archives Select Month February 2012  (2) January 2012  (11) December 2011  (9) November 2011  (10) October 2011  (13) September 2011  (15) August 2011  (11) July 2011  (8) June 2011  (7) May 2011  (9) April 2011  (10) March 2011  (13) February 2011  (10) January 2011  (13) December 2010  (17) November 2010  (17) October 2010  (15) September 2010  (15) August 2010  (15) July 2010  (12) June 2010  (19) May 2010  (8) April 2010  (9) March 2010  (19) February 2010  (11) January 2010  (13) December 2009  (13) November 2009  (14) October 2009  (15) September 2009  (11) August 2009  (11) July 2009  (14) June 2009  (12) May 2009  (12) April 2009  (15) March 2009  (19) February 2009  (20) January 2009  (18) December 2008  (14) November 2008  (9) October 2008  (11) September 2008  (12) August 2008  (8) July 2008  (9) June 2008  (9) May 2008  (9) April 2008  (12) March 2008  (13) February 2008  (11) January 2008  (16) December 2007  (7) November 2007  (7) October 2007  (14) September 2007  (14) August 2007  (15) July 2007  (16) June 2007  (13) May 2007  (14) April 2007  (16) March 2007  (28) February 2007  (21) January 2007  (24) December 2006  (22) November 2006  (17) October 2006  (13) September 2006  (5) August 2006  (3) July 2006  (6) June 2006  (5) Categories Select Category Awards  (22) Change  (21) Channel  (7) Communications  (12) Compensation  (1) Consumer  (4) Employee  (38) Games  (2) General Business  (21) General Motivation  (33) Incentive 101  (36) Incentive Industry  (18) Incentive Inquisition  (1) Influence  (15) Just Fun  (1) Loyalty  (3) Measurement  (6) Merchandise  (4) Motivation Science  (10) Other Postings  (9) Program Design  (38) Recognition  (26) Science  (5) Travel  (2) Uncategorized  (817) Web/Tech  (11) Weblogs  (4) /* 0 ) { location.href = "http://www.i2i-align.com/?cat="+dropdown.optionsdropdown.selectedIndex.value; } } dropdown.onchange = onCatChange; /* ]]> */ Other Links […]

  6. […] Incentives May Not Trump Culture (symbolist.com) […]

Leave a Reply